Getting stuff right is normally regarded as science’s central aim. But a new analysis has raised the existential spectre that universities, laboratory chiefs and academic journals are contributing to the “natural selection of bad science”.
To thrive in the cut-throat world of academia, scientists are incentivised to publish surprising findings frequently, the study suggests – despite the risk that such findings are “most likely to be wrong”.
Paul Smaldino, a cognitive scientist who led the work at the University of California, Merced, said: “As long as the incentives are in place that reward publishing novel, surprising results, often and in high-visibility journals above other, more nuanced aspects of science, shoddy practices that maximise one’s ability to do so will run rampant.”
The paper comes as psychologists and biomedical scientists are grappling with an apparent replication crisis, in which many high profile results have been shown to be unreliable. Observations that striking a power pose will make you feel bolder, smiling makes you feel happy or that placing a pair of “big brother” eyes on the wall will protect against theft have all failed to stand up to replication.
paranoid-torpeodo liked this dawnhasrisen liked this
justafetusinthewomboflife liked this exhausted-rebel-scientist reblogged this from scinerds
vie-belle-vie liked this translesbiantheo liked this
randaness liked this
anonymous-physicist reblogged this from landunderthewave
landunderthewave reblogged this from queerintheory queerintheory reblogged this from greenskyoverme
greenskyoverme reblogged this from anarmyofawesome
anarmyofawesome reblogged this from fleshengineer
vaguely-none liked this
anarmyofawesome liked this fleshengineer reblogged this from meeresbande
fleshengineer liked this
meeresbande reblogged this from meeres-care-blog
meeresbande liked this
jellyfish-rabbit-bear reblogged this from meeres-care-blog
jellyfish-rabbit-bear liked this meeres-care-blog reblogged this from scinerds
awfullynice-portal reblogged this from scinerds
the-penandpaper liked this
meeres-care-blog liked this
thesapphireeastsea liked this
studylix reblogged this from studyflxwer
studyflxwer reblogged this from biopsychs
luarenah liked this
dragonsand liked this a-little-neuro reblogged this from biopsychs
peripheralnerves liked this
biopsychs reblogged this from scinerds swiftseraph liked this
livrerie liked this
taggthewanderer reblogged this from blancaleona
taggthewanderer liked this
blancaleona reblogged this from unnounblr tardistogongen liked this
dontpokethekitty liked this
mayes-the-fox reblogged this from dontpokethekitty
machinamuros reblogged this from lunanier
scinerds posted this - Show more notes